Payroll Recruitment: Our Experience, Hire Payroll Specialists

Tsiala Jobava

Last updated on February 8, 2026 | 17 min read

AccountingFinanceIT recruitmentRecruitment

• Learn why payroll recruitment is more complex than general HR hiring and which skills truly define a reliable payroll specialist.
• Discover how DevsData LLC’s structured three-stage vetting process helps companies in Europe and the US hire payroll professionals who ensure compliance and stability.

Introduction

Few things test employee trust like payroll errors. A delayed paycheck, an underpayment, or a missing bonus can turn a normal workday into a crisis of confidence. And it happens more often than most companies realize – over half of US workers report experiencing payroll issues, from late deposits to inaccurate deductions. Nearly half say two mistakes are enough to make them consider quitting. Payroll, therefore, isn’t just about numbers; it’s about reliability. Hiring the right payroll specialists means safeguarding accuracy, compliance, and the trust that keeps teams together.

At DevsData LLC, we have developed strong expertise in payroll recruitment across the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, Austria, and Poland. Our projects range from building in-house payroll teams to supplying interim staff during peak periods. We connect companies with payroll administrators, managers, and consultants who can both run payroll smoothly and redesign processes when compliance or transparency challenges arise.

What is payroll recruitment?

Payroll recruitment isn’t simply about finding someone to process paychecks, but about hiring professionals who ensure accuracy and maintain employee trust. Unlike general HR or finance roles, payroll specialists work at the intersection of regulation, technology, and human impact. They are responsible for ensuring that every salary and tax deduction aligns with complex local laws while maintaining flawless timing. That’s why payroll hiring demands a specialized, detail-oriented approach - one that screens for both technical mastery and absolute integrity.

Payroll specialists typically oversee and manage payment systems, including salaries, bonuses, and benefits. They ensure every transaction is accurate and on time, all while staying up to date with tax legislation and employment regulations. In many cases, they also integrate payroll operations with HR and finance systems, ensuring that reporting is transparent and audit-ready.

Given that payroll often constitutes one of the largest expenses for a business (and directly affects every employee’s livelihood), recruiting capable payroll professionals is a strategic investment. The right hire ensures every hour worked is accounted for, every deduction is correct, and every paycheck arrives as expected.

Key skills to look for when hiring a payroll specialist

When hiring a payroll professional, employers should assess a blend of technical expertise, formal certifications, and practical reliability. Drawing on both industry standards (from organizations such as the American Payroll Association and Korn Ferry) and DevsData LLC’s extensive recruitment experience across Europe and the United States, several key factors consistently determine the success of a payroll hire:

• Relevant certifications
  Credentials signal dedication and knowledge. The Fundamental Payroll Certification (FPC) is often seen as an entry point into the profession, while the Certified Payroll Professional (CPP) designation signals advanced expertise. These accreditations are especially valuable in markets such as the US or UK, where payroll legislation is complex and layered. Certification not only demonstrates mastery of payroll concepts but also commitment to staying current on laws and best practices.
• Hands-on experience
  Strong candidates usually have experience in complex payroll environments. Many come from large organizations where they manage intricate pay structures, diverse benefit plans, and heavy compliance oversight. Such experience proves they can handle the scale and demands of a multinational or multi-state company without compromising accuracy. It’s a bonus if they have experience across different industries or countries, as that broadens their understanding of various payroll regulations and systems.
• Compliance and regulatory knowledge
  Payroll specialists must pair technical proficiency with a deep knowledge of compliance. They are expected to be fully aware of evolving tax laws, labor codes, and directives. For example, the upcoming EU Pay Transparency Directive (with requirements taking effect by 2026) will force many employers to disclose salary ranges and publish pay equity data. More than 70% of organizations believe these new rules will affect them, but fewer than 10% feel well prepared to comply. A payroll expert who cannot adapt to such changes may put the entire company at risk of legal and financial penalties.
• Meticulous attention to detail and ethics
  Payroll is a high-stakes function where even minor errors can have significant consequences. A single miscalculation could result in employees being paid incorrectly or incorrect tax filings, which can lead to fines (for instance, in the UK, mistakes in payroll tax reporting can trigger penalties up to £3000 per error). Employers should look for professionals who demonstrate integrity and a track record of error-free work. They must handle sensitive data with discretion and maintain confidentiality at all times. Nothing less than total accuracy is acceptable when people’s pay and a company’s compliance are at stake.
• Communication and customer-service mindset
  Although payroll work is numbers-driven, it is also highly people-facing. Payroll specialists often need to explain paycheck computations, deductions, or resolve issues for employees who have questions about their pay. Clear, patient communication and a service-oriented approach ensure that issues are addressed professionally and without friction. This is crucial because trust in payroll is fragile, about 26% of workers said they would seek new employment after just a single payroll mistake. A payroll professional with strong interpersonal skills can turn a potential issue into a positive interaction, maintaining employees’ confidence that their concerns are heard and addressed.
• Technical savvy and software adaptability
  Modern payroll operations rely on specialized software (like ADP, Workday, or SAP SuccessFactors) as well as integration with general business tools (Excel, QuickBooks, cloud-based HRIS, etc.). A top payroll specialist is comfortable navigating these systems and can quickly learn new ones. They should be able to not only use payroll platforms but also extract and analyze data for reporting. In fact, payroll teams are becoming increasingly tech-driven – roughly 67% of organizations now have dedicated IT/data specialists in their payroll teams, and about 61% have analytical reporting experts on board. This trend shows that payroll professionals who can bridge the gap between accounting, compliance, and technology are especially valuable. An ideal candidate will demonstrate both hard skills (such as proficiency in payroll software and Excel) and digital agility, adopting new tools and automating processes to improve efficiency.

Services in payroll recruitment

Payroll recruitment at DevsData LLC is structured around precision and context. The company’s process covers the entire hiring cycle – from defining requirements and assessing compliance risks to verifying technical and system-specific expertise. Each recruitment is tailored to the employer’s environment, ensuring that the selected professionals can integrate smoothly and maintain operational accuracy. Different business needs call for different types of payroll specialists, which is why DevsData offers several staffing models, each suited to specific timelines and organizational priorities.

Payroll recruitment models offered by DevsData LLC

By tailoring the recruitment approach to these different needs, DevsData LLC ensures that companies, whether they require a short-term fix or a long-term solution, get professionals who fit the mission.

Challenges in payroll recruitment

Recruiting payroll professionals comes with specific challenges that set it apart from general HR hiring. Understanding these challenges is the first step to overcoming them:

Limited talent pool

Payroll is a niche field, and truly experienced payroll specialists are in short supply. In some markets (such as Germany or the UK, known for complex payroll regulations), demand far outstrips the supply of seasoned experts. According to US industry surveys, 48% of employers reported difficulty finding payroll talent within the past two years – a shortage that continues to strain compliance and operational continuity. In other words, employers are often fishing in a small pond. This talent scarcity sometimes forces businesses to get creative. For example, approximately 67% of employers admit to having had to train existing non-payroll staff to cover payroll duties due to the shortage. The challenge for recruiters is not only identifying qualified candidates, but also persuading them to make a move and join a new organization.

Constantly evolving regulations

Payroll professionals must hit a moving target of compliance. Tax laws and labor regulations evolve constantly, demanding agility and precision. Recent pay transparency initiatives across Europe, for example, are reshaping how payroll teams handle equity and reporting.

Multifaceted skill requirements

A payroll specialist needs a rare mix of skills. They must master payroll systems and financial calculations while staying up to date on changing tax and labor laws. Equally important is their professionalism – handling sensitive data with absolute integrity and focus, even under pressure. This combination makes payroll recruitment a search for truly multifaceted professionals. As payroll departments evolve, many now include dedicated IT or data analytics experts, and more than half employ compliance specialists to support their function. Still, in smaller firms, one person often carries all these responsibilities.

Global and cross-border complexity

Companies that operate in multiple countries (or hire remote employees abroad) need payroll staff who can navigate cross-border regulations and coordinate with international teams. Each country has its own tax laws and reporting standards, making payroll management across jurisdictions exponentially more complex than managing it in a single country. This narrows the candidate pool further: a payroll expert might be great in one country’s rules but inexperienced with another’s. Companies expanding into new regions often find that specialized recruitment help is essential, because general HR recruiters may not know where to find (or how to vet) a payroll specialist with specific country knowledge.

In summary, payroll recruitment is more complex than general HR hiring due to a smaller talent pool, higher stakes in compliance, the need for hybrid skill sets, and often a global scope. Each of these challenges can be addressed with the right approach, and that’s where our experience at DevsData LLC comes into play.

How DevsData LLC helps you hire payroll specialists

Website: www.devsdata.com
Company size: ~60 employees
Founding year: 2016
Headquarters: Brooklyn, NY, and Warsaw, Poland

At DevsData LLC, payroll recruitment is one of the areas where we apply our structured and rigorous approach. We have successfully hired payroll specialists for both internal needs within our company and for external clients across Poland, Germany, Austria, the United Kingdom, and the United States. We understand that a payroll hire must be immediately trustworthy and effective – there is little room for a learning curve when people’s paychecks and compliance are on the line.

The first stage is a technical exercise, when candidates are asked to complete a payroll calculation under strict time limits. These tasks mirror real-world scenarios, overtime adjustments, new benefit enrollments, or tax changes mid-cycle, and reveal whether someone can work accurately under pressure.

Those who excel move on to a live case study. Here, we simulate the kinds of issues payroll specialists encounter daily, from handling a regulatory change mid-pay period to investigating an employee’s complaint about a pay slip. This stage tests not just their technical knowledge, but also their ability to think on their feet and communicate under pressure.

The final stage is a combination of a technical exam and an in-depth interview. Candidates demonstrate their understanding of advanced topics such as year-end reporting or expat payroll, while also discussing how they’ve navigated high-stakes situations in the past. By the end, we have a complete picture of their expertise, decision-making, and character.

Through this rigorous funnel, only a select few candidates make it through, saving clients time by ensuring only proven specialists are interviewed. We also prioritize professionals with experience at large companies, as they are skilled at managing complex payroll systems, benefits, and compliance across multiple regions – making them especially valuable for companies preparing to scale. This structured, high-trust approach has earned us consistent 5/5 ratings on Clutch and GoodFirms, reinforcing our reputation for reliability and client satisfaction.

DevsData LLC’s international reach allows us to match payroll talent to each client’s regional context. In Germany, that may mean a long-term manager fluent in local tax systems; in the UK, an interim consultant to rebuild processes; in the US, a specialist with multi-state payroll expertise. Our recruitment combines rigorous vetting with contextual matching – ensuring you don’t just hire “a payroll person,” but the right specialist for your specific needs, whether maintaining stability or driving transformation.

This approach has already proven successful in finance-related projects. For example, we supported a London-based investment fund in hiring engineers with financial-sector expertise and helped a proprietary trading firm recruit top-performing traders and portfolio managers. These experiences highlight our ability to deliver not only IT talent but also highly specialized financial professionals under demanding conditions.

Looking to strengthen your payroll operations with experienced, fully vetted professionals? DevsData LLC connects companies across the US and Europe with top-tier payroll specialists who ensure compliance and reliability. Contact DevsData LLC at [email protected] or visit our website at www.devsdata.com.

Conclusion

Payroll directly reflects how a company values accuracy, accountability, and trust. Each payment reinforces employees’ confidence in the organization. When companies invest in hiring the right payroll specialists, they are safeguarding both their workforce’s confidence and their own reputation.

At DevsData LLC, we understand the weight of that responsibility. Our structured three-stage vetting process, international reach across Poland, Germany, Austria, the UK, and the US, and our focus on both technical precision and compliance expertise allow us to deliver payroll professionals who truly make a difference. From detail-oriented administrators who ensure daily accuracy, to strategic consultants who guide cross-border compliance, we help companies build payroll functions that scale, adapt, and inspire trust.

Effective payroll recruitment ensures reliability where it matters most. Skilled specialists maintain compliance, prevent costly errors, and strengthen employees’ trust in every payment. With the right people in place, payroll becomes a consistent, transparent process that supports business stability and growth.

Discover how IT recruitment and staffing can address your talent needs. Explore trending regions like Poland, Portugal, Mexico, Brazil and more.

🗓️ Schedule a consultation

Read full bio

Tsiala Jobava Copywriter and Marketer

Tsiala Jobava is a talented marketing specialist from Georgia. Tsiala holds a bachelor’s degree in International Relations from Georgian American University and a master’s in Marketing and Communication from Barcelona Business School. She has built a diverse career, working as a copywriter and in marketing and PR, before returning to her first passion – writing. Along the way, she has gained valuable experience in social media management, content creation, and brand development.

Read more about our IT staffing services

AccountingFinanceIT recruitmentRecruitment